🇺🇸 New York Pastrami Sandwich

New York Pastrami Sandwich (Photo: star5112, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons)© star5112 · CC BY-SA 2.0 · Wikimedia Commons

The pastrami sandwich is one of New York’s great classics: thin slices of salted, peppered and slow-cooked beef, served warm on rye bread with mustard. Pastrami came to the United States with Romanian Jewish immigrants in the late 19th century and became a symbol of New York delis.

In New York, I stopped at the Brooklyn Diner, a real 1950s American diner close to Central Park, with leather seats and rock’n’roll in the background. The famous pastrami sandwiches are on the menu there, next to burgers and milkshakes.

Here is the traditional recipe so you can make it at home. It is simple, but it needs patience, because the brine takes five days. The result is tender, peppery meat that is truly worth the wait.

The recipe

Classic recipe

The traditional recipe for the dish, not the one from the restaurant where I tasted it.

Servings
6
Prep
40 min
Cook
4 h 30
Rest
122 h
Total
127 h 10
Difficulty
Hard

Ingredients

Brine

  • 2 kg beef brisket (point or navel cut)
  • 2 l water
  • 120 g coarse salt
  • 60 g brown sugar
  • 15 g pink curing salt (nitrite)
  • 4 garlic cloves, crushed
  • 2 tbsp pickling spices (mustard seeds, coriander, peppercorns, cloves)
  • 3 bay leaves

Spice crust

  • 3 tbsp coarsely crushed black pepper
  • 2 tbsp coarsely crushed coriander seeds
  • 1 tbsp sweet paprika
  • 1 tsp garlic powder
  • 1 tsp mustard seeds
  • 1 tbsp brown sugar

Sandwiches (6)

  • 12 slices rye bread
  • 3 tbsp yellow mustard
  • 6 dill pickles

Method

  1. Make the brine: bring the water to a gentle simmer with the coarse salt, sugar, curing salt, garlic, spices and bay leaves, stirring until everything has dissolved. Let it cool completely, then chill it. Never pour warm brine over the meat.
  2. Submerge the brisket in the brine, in a large container or a food bag, making sure it is fully covered. Keep it in the fridge for 5 days, below 4 °C, turning the meat once a day.
  3. Take the meat out, rinse it and soak it for 2 hours in cold water, changing the water once. Pat it dry thoroughly with paper towels.
  4. Mix all the spice crust ingredients and coat the whole surface of the meat, pressing firmly. Leave it for 30 minutes at room temperature while the oven heats to 120 °C.
  5. Place the meat, fat side up, on a rack over a tray holding 1 cm of water. Cook for about 4 hours at 120 °C, until the core reaches 90 °C and a knife slides in easily. If the crust darkens too much, cover it with foil.
  6. Wrap the meat in foil and let it rest for 30 minutes. Slice it very thinly across the grain, then steam the slices for 5 minutes so they are warm and melting.
  7. Build the sandwiches: spread mustard on the rye bread, pile about 150 g of pastrami on each sandwich, close and cut in half. Serve with the dill pickles.

Tips and variations

  • No time for the brine? Ask your butcher for a ready-salted beef brisket (corned beef), then go straight to the spice crust.
  • Always slice very thinly and across the grain: this is what makes pastrami tender.
  • Cooked meat keeps for 5 days in the fridge, well wrapped, or 3 months in the freezer in portions. Reheat it by steaming.
  • Reuben variation: add sauerkraut, Swiss cheese and Thousand Island dressing, then toast the sandwich in a pan.
  • Pink curing salt contains nitrite: follow the dose on the packet and never use it as table salt.

Recipe shared for guidance only, adapt it to your equipment: times and temperatures may vary. Check for allergens (gluten, milk, eggs, fish, shellfish, nuts, sesame…) and make sure ingredients are fresh. Raw or undercooked fish, meat and eggs are not recommended for pregnant women, young children, elderly or vulnerable people. Take care with hot oil, flambéing and alcohol. I am not a health or nutrition professional.

Photo: star5112, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons